Fixed vs Variable Mortgage Renewal: How to Decide in 2026

Fixed vs Variable Mortgage Renewal: How to Decide in 2026

Fixed gives you a payment you can plan around, and variable gives you flexibility and usually a smaller penalty if you break the term early. Neither is “right” for everyone. The better choice at renewal depends on how much payment surprise you can absorb, how likely you are to move or refinance before the term ends, and which type of variable mortgage you would actually be signing.

I get this question from homeowners in Barrie, Simcoe County and across the GTA every renewal season. Here is how I walk people through it, without predicting where rates are going, because nobody can do that reliably.

The basic difference

  • Fixed rate: your interest rate is set for the whole term (often 1 to 5 years). Your payment does not change.
  • Variable rate: your rate moves with your lender’s prime rate, which follows the Bank of Canada’s policy rate. What happens to your payment depends on the type of variable mortgage (more on that below).

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) explains both on its interest on mortgages page, including the risks of variable-rate mortgages with fixed payments.

Two kinds of variable mortgage (this matters more than people think)

Not every variable mortgage behaves the same way when rates change. Ask your lender, in writing, which one you are being offered.

  • Adjustable-rate mortgage: your payment changes whenever the rate changes. Your principal payoff stays on track, but your cash flow moves.
  • Variable rate with fixed payments: your payment stays the same, but the split between interest and principal shifts. If rates rise far enough, you can reach what FCAC calls the trigger rate, the point where your payment covers only interest. Past that, unpaid interest is generally added to your balance, which is called negative amortization.

If you are offered a fixed-payment variable, ask what your trigger rate is. Lenders must disclose it in your mortgage documents. FCAC’s guidance on this is covered in its mortgage relief options page.

Side-by-side comparison

QuestionFixedVariable
Payment predictabilityHigh: same payment all termDepends: may change, or principal paydown may shift
Typical penalty to break earlyOften the greater of three months’ interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), which can be largeUsually three months’ interest
Best fitTight budgets, low tolerance for payment changesCushion in the budget, may sell or refinance before the term ends
Main riskLocking in and then needing to leave earlyRates rise and your cash flow or principal paydown suffers

Penalty calculations vary by lender, and the IRD method in particular can differ a lot between a big bank and a monoline lender. Read the penalty clause before you sign, not after.

A worked example (illustration only)

Say you are renewing a $400,000 balance on a 25-year amortization. Illustration only, using made-up rates: at a 4.5% rate, the monthly payment is roughly $2,200. If the rate were 1 percentage point higher, at 5.5%, the payment on an adjustable-rate mortgage would be roughly $2,440, or about $230 more per month. If that extra $230 would strain your budget, that is a signal toward fixed. If it would not, and you value lower break costs, variable deserves a serious look. These are not quotes or predictions.

A simple way to decide: 6 questions

  1. Could you handle a payment about $200 to $400 higher per month? If not, lean fixed.
  2. Is a move, sale or refinance likely before the term ends? If yes, the break penalty matters, and that often favours variable, or a shorter fixed term.
  3. Do you have other big payments coming? Kids’ tuition, a business loan or a second property can change your risk tolerance.
  4. Is your income steady? Self-employed or commission-based owners often prefer certainty. I cover that in my guide for self-employed mortgages in Ontario.
  5. If variable, is your payment fixed or adjustable? And what is the trigger rate?
  6. Does the lender allow you to convert variable to fixed later? Ask what rate they would offer at conversion.

What to do before you accept your lender’s renewal offer

Your lender’s renewal letter is an offer, not the final word. FCAC notes that federally regulated lenders must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before your term ends, and that you may qualify for a lower rate than the one quoted in the letter. Its renew your mortgage page suggests shopping around a few months before the end of your term.

  • Ask your current lender for both a fixed and a variable offer, and for the penalty terms on each.
  • Get at least one competing quote from another lender or through a broker.
  • Don’t extend your amortization just to lower your payment unless you have to: it adds interest over time.
  • If you are thinking of switching lenders, check the rules. OSFI exempts a “straight switch” of an uninsured mortgage between federally regulated lenders (same balance, no longer amortization) from the minimum qualifying rate stress test, though the new lender still has to approve you. See OSFI’s announcement. Credit unions and private lenders may follow different rules.

I explain how to push for a better deal in Can You Negotiate Your Mortgage Renewal?, and the full process is on my mortgage renewal page.

Is a shorter fixed term a middle path?

Sometimes. A 1- or 2-year fixed term gives you payment certainty without a long commitment, and a lower penalty exposure if your plans change. The trade-off is that you will be renewing again soon, so you will face the same decision and any rate changes sooner. Use the mortgage calculator to compare payments at different rates and terms before you decide.

Common mistakes I see at renewal

  • Signing the renewal letter as-is. The first offer is rarely the best one available, and a quick call or a competing quote can change it.
  • Choosing only on the lowest rate. A slightly lower rate with a harsh penalty clause can cost far more if life changes mid-term.
  • Not asking which type of variable it is. A fixed-payment variable and an adjustable-rate variable carry different risks, as covered above.
  • Leaving it to the last week. Switching lenders takes time for appraisals, documents and approval, so starting early keeps your options open.
  • Ignoring the rest of your finances. If you carry higher-interest debt, it may be worth asking whether rolling it into your mortgage makes sense at renewal. It is not right for everyone, so run the numbers first.

A short checklist for your renewal conversation

  1. Write down your current balance, rate, maturity date and remaining amortization.
  2. List your plans for the next five years: moving, renovating, having kids, changing jobs, or retiring.
  3. Decide how much monthly payment movement you can comfortably absorb.
  4. Collect at least two written offers, fixed and variable, with penalty terms.
  5. Ask about prepayment privileges, such as annual lump sums and payment increases.

FAQ

Is variable always cheaper than fixed?

No. Whether variable ends up cheaper depends on how rates move during your term, which nobody can promise. Compare the real offers you receive, and weigh the penalty and payment risk, not only the starting rate.

Can I switch from variable to fixed during my term?

Many lenders allow it, but the fixed rate you get is the lender’s rate on that day, and conditions vary. Ask about conversion terms before you sign.

Do I have to renew with my current lender?

No. You can switch lenders at renewal. Allow time for approval, and ask about any fees. FCAC suggests starting a few months before your term ends.

What is a trigger rate?

On a variable-rate mortgage with fixed payments, it is the interest rate at which your payment only covers interest. Beyond it, you may start adding to your balance. Lenders must disclose it in your mortgage documents.

Renewing in the next 6 months and not sure which way to go? Get my options or call me at 416-800-9098. I’ll compare fixed and variable offers side by side, including the penalty terms, so you can choose with real numbers.

David Le, Mortgage Agent Level 1 (FSRA licence M25000475), The Genesis Group, brokerage licence #12861. This article is general information, not personal financial advice. All mortgages and loans are subject to lender approval and qualification.

Related Posts

keyboard_arrow_up